Friday, 19 January 2024

Critique: Invisible City (Series One)

Eric, an environmental police officer, gets back to work after his wife dies in a forest fire. He investigates the death of a river dolphin and gets entangled in a world of Brazilian mythical creatures (known as ‘entities’ in the show). These are ruled by Ines, the cuca. Other important characters include Luna, Eric’s daughter, and Camila, an iara (siren).

 

*****SPOILERS*****

 

 

Positives

 

There are many things to celebrate.

The opening credits were spectacular. Whilst the duration was longer than I typically like, each moment was used wisely. The length was thus the correct choice.

The actors of Eric and Camila were amazing, showing great skill.

The body of the dead river dolphin transforms into the shape of a human. Ines made blue butterflies swarm over the it and then they fly off, the body disappearing into a cloud of even more butterflies. This was beautiful to watch. Not only visually but the purpose behind it: Ines wanted to protect the entities from humanity’s curiosity and fear.

We see a piglet eating a bowl of fruit and it’s adorable. But then the piglet puts a hoof into the bowl and this was a cuteness overload. It’s still chewing as it’s picked up and that could have killed me with happiness. How much of this was planned and how much was accidental I don’t know. I’m just happy it happened.

 

 

Problems

 

At one point, Luna wakes up. She alternates between screaming, breathing heavily, and shouting for her grandma. I found this a weird combo. A scream as she woke up would have been fine, but to intersperse a few in the middle was too weird and unnatural.

 

Curupira going back into the forest caused most of the issues.

He starts writhing around, making all these weird body movements and weird screams. His facial expression throughout the show have been utterly bizarre so this fits with the characterisation, but why this weird characterisation was included I don’t know. It seems unnecessary because it doesn’t add anything to the show.

These screams weren’t in pain or in fear. Eric follows animals calls which lead to Curupira. But Curupira’s screams are definitely human. So why he was screaming I don’t know.

 

 

Questions

 

Some things were problematic but there could be something to explain them away. I say ‘could’ because they’re not immediately present and I’m just grasping at straws.

There is occasional use of the word ‘fuck’. That’s fine. But no other swear words are used in the show. Usually stronger swears are accompanied by weaker ones because going straight in with one of the strongest is off. Maybe this is a translation error. Maybe in Portuguese, their equivalent of ‘fuck’ isn’t considered as harsh a swearword as it is in English.

Isac starts talking about Curupira drinking too much alcohol but halfway through saying ‘alcohol’, he changes this to ‘coffee’. Um, what? Is talking to kids about alcohol in Brazilian culture bad? I can’t think of any other explanation for this weird behaviour.

Throughout the show, the butterflies land on people’s faces and the eyes on the wings are positioned over the eyes on the face. This is a nice touch. Although the butterflies are blue on top and brown-with-eyes below: when they land and spread their wings, it should be the upside (the blue) showing, not the underneath (the brown). But these are magical butterflies which are the result of the shapeshifting cuca, so shifting their shape to flip the wing patterns isn’t unplausible.

 

 

 

Conclusion

 

All-in-all, this was an enjoyable show. The animation and the acting were done well, as were the clothing designs. It’s clear that a lot of effort went into producing it. It kept me intrigued the whole way through.

No comments:

Post a Comment