Friday, 4 June 2021

Critique: Your Honour

The quality of acting was phenomenal, particularly the characters of Adam and Big Mo. They are my joint favourite characters. I’m not usually taken in by criminal badasses but Big Mo was just perfect.

 

*****SPOILERS*****

 

Adam visits the sight of his mother’s murder on the first anniversary, 9th October. Being intimidated to leave (then follow), Adam accidentally kills a guy. Michael, a judge and Adam’s father, takes Adam to the police station but when he learns the guy was Rocko, son of mob boss Jimmy Baxter, Michael decides they need a cover-up.

Michael asks a favour from his friend Charlie who makes Kofi get rid of the car. The police think it’s stolen so Kofi is blamed for Rocko’s death. Charlie makes sure Kofi takes the fall.

            (Admittedly, this was via torture: Kofi is locked in a car with rising CO2 levels, making it harder to breathe. This scene has intermittent flashes of Adam using his inhaler, making it easier to breathe. Both Kofi and Adam are exposed to gas but to different effects. That was a great bit of cinematography.)

            Michael is the judge of Kofi’s case. Considering Kofi is accused of stealing Michael’s dead wife’s car, I’m surprised Michael’s allowed to judge it.

Once Kofi is sentenced, Adam stands in the empty courtroom on the accused side. So Adam feels guilty for Rocko’s death and Kofi’s prison time. As Kofi dies and other events unfold, this guilt keeps on eating away at Adam. You can see the weight of it all by Adam’s mannerism and posture.

 

 

Adam and Frannie

 

In the first scene of episode one, Adam wakes up with a woman in his bed. As the episode goes on, as things get worse and worse and Adam gets more and more scared, his whole demeanour diminishes so that appears years younger. It’s like his age went from twenty-four to fourteen.

Show naked Adam and Frannie in very first scene. Don’t see nakedness any other time in show. Yes, it was good to see them in bed to solidify that they were together but nakedness wasn’t needed to emphasise the point.

It turns out that the woman he’s seeing, Frannie, is his photography teacher. Adam being seventeen means it’s not illegal but shagging your pupils must be against school policy. Frannie stepped in when Adam’s mother died. So Frannie is his surrogate mother… and he’s shagging her? Mummy issues.

Adam starts seeing Sophia, sister of Rocko. It was disappointing to see him cheat on Frannie. But: he’s a bundle of emotions; he can date Sophia out in the open but not Frannie; and he’s obsessed with Rocko so being with his sister is an extension of this. None of this makes cheating okay, of course, but it does make it understandable.

Near the start in photography class, Adam said of photographer Vivian “I love her. Like, really, really love her” and it was clear Adam was talking about Frannie. Later, Adam and Weasley seem to be friends again (if not a little awkward) and Frannie asks to see Adam. Frannie says has put in her notice: Adam’s nearly eighteen so they won’t have to hide their relationship so Frannie’s applying for jobs near MCU, Adam’s chosen university. Considering Adam wants to stay in New Orleans with Sophia, this is unfortunate on Frannie’s part.

            Frannie sees Adam and Sophia holding hands and says high when they sit down in a café. Frannie asks Sophia if she has Italian roots: on mum’s side (dad’s side is Scottish, yet everything’s been done to make dad look like Italian mob boss). Frannie repeats Adam’s words about Vivian. Ouch! Later they meet alone and Frannie says Adam’s simply fascinated with her because he killed her brother. I’m glad I’m not the only one who noticed!

            Once Charlie knows about Adam and Frannie, he approaches her in a bar. She was always a young teacher but she’s shed her years, appearing almost childlike. Frannie can’t tell if Charlie’s campaigning or hitting on her. That’s brilliant. Then he replies that she should know what’s appropriate because she’s a teacher. Burn! What Charlie says is open to interpretation yet Frannie right there admits to it. Charlie tells her to end it with Adam and Frannie replies that it will hurt sensitive, seventeen year-old Adam. Charlie’s reply? “Exactly.” Ouch. But then Frannie says it’s a shame a seventeen year-old left someone to die in the gutter. What a way for Charlie to find out what Adam did! It put him on the back-foot for the first time.

 

 

Michael’s Deception

 

For a judge of all people to cover up a crime is awful. Yet Michael’s first duty is for the safety of his child.

Michael is smooth at lying. I won’t say he’s ‘good’. It’s just that with all the lying he’s seen in court, he knows what makes a bad lie, so he knows what to avoid. Mob boss thinks Michael killed Rocko and Michael, of course, doesn’t correct him in order to save Adam from danger.

The guy who tried to blackmail Michael barely knew anything. But Michael tells the mob boss Jimmy Baxter that the blackmail guy knew everything, just so the blackmailer would be murdered and thus no longer a problem.

The police officer Nancy has photos which Michael explains by saying Robin cheated. So either Michael has to tell Adam that his mum was a cheater or Michael has to tell Adam he said that to cover their tracks. Michael goes for the former and Adam doesn’t react badly (maybe it made him think about his own cheating?)

 

 

Carlo’s Trial

 

Carlo, Rocko’s brother, kills Kofi in jail. His lawyer gets so frustrated with Carlo which was simply hilarious to watch.

On Michael’s birthday, he throws the blackmailer into the sea, Carlo Baxter is arrested for killing Kofi, and then Carlo’s bail hearing is held on the same day. But on many occasions, people complain how slow the New Orlean’s justice system is, so how can the first hearing of the case be held on the same day as the arrest? For that matter, how is the case concluded so quickly? Michael only survives because says can save Carlo from conviction and hence from execution.

I’m surprised that Michael is allowed to be a judge on the Carlo case. Carlo killed Kofi and Kofi (everyone believes) killed Carlo’s brother with Michael’s dead wife’s car. So Michael could be biased to let Carlo off the hook.

During court case, Michael lets Carlo’s bestie stand witness, even though he knows the friend has incriminating evidence. The mob boss is furious but Michael slipped medication into the friend so that he needed to go to hospital. This meant that as the defence couldn’t cross-examine him, all of his evidence had to be discounted. This was clever on Michael’s part: to not allow bestie to testify would have been suspicious and thus put the whole trial in jeopardy.

This court case contained my favourite conversation. Carlo says he feared for his life when Kofi shut the prison cell door and after their kafuffle Kofi walked out. McGhee, the prosecutor, says the doors can’t be opened from the inside. (In his anger, Carlo calls McGhee ‘a stupid cunt’.) McGhee then shows the video footage: Kofi didn’t shut the door. With Carlo’s whole defence in pieces, McGhee asks, ‘Who’s the stupid cunt now.’ Honestly, that is perfection.

Carlo found not guilty of murder. But how? None of the evidence pointed that way. Michael did change the verdict that the jury wrote on paper but at least one of them would know the verdict read out wasn’t the one they reached.

Michael bans media or observers from witnesses the trial, other than the families of those accused. Lee and Nancy are sensible exceptions, the former being lawyer for the deceased and Nancy being the police officer who investigated him. Adam is allowed in, though I don’t understand why. How does being the son of a judge let you bend the rules? Yes, this whole show is about corruption but letting Adam into the court room is complete, obvious and public disregard of the law.

 

 

The Charade Unravels

 

Michael manages to keep the charade going despite some unravelling. But nearing the end of the series, those closest to Michael start to pull the threads (and the lies) free.

            Nancy does some digging. She goes to the graveyard and asks the homeless guy if he saw a father and son on the 9th (the same day Rocko died.) The homeless guy say no, they came on the 10th. Plus the court records show Michael was in court at that time on the 9th. So yes, both these things are suspicious, but I don’t understand why Nancy went to the graveyard in the first place. What made her want to investigate Michael’s claims?

            Lee, Kofi’s lawyer, learns from Big Mo that Kofi didn’t have the car on the day Rocko died. So she thinks Adam and Michael are the only ones who could have driven that car on the day Rocko died. (Never mind it could have been stolen on the 9th, like Michael said, and then taken by Kofi on the 10th. Of course we know this didn’t happen but Lee doesn’t even see it as a possibility.)

            So in both these cases, I’m not convinced that the unravelling of Michael’s deceptions is feasible. It was excellent for the plot, don’t get me wrong, but it wasn’t executed as well as it could be.

 

 

Heart-breaking Ending

 

Adam’s baseball was in Kofi’s possessions (because baseball and Kofi were in the car together) so Eugene inherited it. Lee sells the baseball to Michael (who recognises it as Adam’s). Eugene uses the money to buy a gun and shoot Carlo but misses and hits Adam in the next. So Adam starts making noises, and blood starts spurting from his mouth, just like Rocko experienced when he died. I didn’t expect that at all. Some people might label it as cosmic justice but it was a fantastic plot twist for me. At Michael got to hug his son as he lay dying. At least, I presume Adam died. If Adam survived, that brings the possibility of a second series which I would be thrilled to watch.

No comments:

Post a Comment