Tuesday, 20 September 2016

Critiques: Inside Out and The Good Dinosaur and Sanjay’s Super Team

Two Pixar films fell below my expectations in 2015: The Good Dinosaur and Inside Out. The saving grace of 2015 for Pixar was Sanjay’s Super Team.


***SPOILERS***


The Good Dinosaur: the title really didn’t encapsulate what the film was about whatsoever. The only way it related to the film was that the main character was a dinosaur, but under that logic, ‘The Good Human’ would be a legitimate name for almost any other production!
A better name would have been ‘The Storm Provides’. This phrase sums up the film nicely as it was clearly the film’s catchphrase (though thankfully not said to the point of annoyance) yet as a title it wouldn’t give the plot away whatsoever.
The story was acceptable. There was a scene reminiscent of The Lion King when the main story arch kicks off: the main character (a son) sees his father get killed by an oncoming force of nature surging past the cliff-face they stand at. It seemed almost lazy to use the same plot device. Of course, in The Good Dinosaur, it’s caused by the storm which is the driving force in the film, so I think that it was still necessary.
I really like how the t-rex ran like horses, seeing as they were cowboys. That had me giggling for a good ten minutes. I also enjoyed seeing the farm that the dinosaurs had built up at the beginning of the film, seeing how it worked and the challenges it faced. I thought that was particularly clever and well thought out.
I didn’t like that the humans howled. I think they did it because dogs howl and dogs are humans’ best friend, so in this world where the dinosaurs are the most intelligent species and the dinosaur’s best friend is a human, perhaps it was to draw the comparison. But it was sloppily done.
Yet there were many things that could be improved. One little girl half way through the film declared, “There! It’s a happy ending. We can go now!”
I wasn’t the only one bored, apparently.
The film definitely had potential. There were loads of positive aspects which I think could have provided the basis for an exceptionally good film.


The short at the beginning of The Good Dinosaur, Sanjay’s Super Team, is my favourite Pixar short of all time. One of my favourite Pixar things all round, actually. (I place it third, behind Finding Nemo and Finding Dory; I will talk about Finding Dory in a later post.)
The details in the animation were so intricate and pretty. It was fantastic that Disney has done its first Hindu animation. One of my favourite aspects was the father patting the floor at the beginning and the son doing the same at the end, inviting the other to join them to see what’s important to the other. The resolution was sweet and simple. A truly lovely short!
I watched this with a friend in the cinema. They knew it was coming but I had absolutely no idea. Afterwards, my friend said they looked forward to seeing my reaction to this short, as they knew it was there but I had no idea. I love all things Asian and particularly all things Indian so I was rather pleased.


I was very excited about watching Inside Out. I found the idea of depicting depression in a child’s film very intriguing and important. The first segment of the film, where the system of the brain and how it worked were explained, was fascinating and very enjoyable.
Toddlers can experience depression so representing it in a friendly medium, by the personification of the emotions, made the concept accessible. The first step to acceptance is understanding; if a toddler’s peers can understand depression even slightly, it makes life so much more bearable.

It was when the story started that I started to dislike the film. The plot was so weak and dissatisfying. It really wasn’t to my taste at all. I was expecting a lot and it just didn’t deliver, which only made me dislike it more. There’s never been an animation that I’ve actively encouraged people not to watch it.

No comments:

Post a Comment